Guaranteed

95.5% Pass Rate

CPA
Intermediate Leval
Company Law April 2023
Suggested Solutions

Company Law
Revision Kit

QUESTION 1a

Q A group of four graduates have decided to form a small business firm to deal in import and export trade. You have been appointed as a member of the technical committee to help in registering the firm as a limited liability company.

Explain to the committee the matters below:

(i) The FIVE legal characteristics of the entity that will be registered.

(ii) FIVE particulars to be included in the company’s Memorandum of Association
A

Solution


(i) Legal Characteristics of the Entity:


A limited liability company (LLC) is a legal entity that combines elements of both a partnership and a corporation. The legal characteristics include:

➢ Limited Liability: Members' personal assets are protected. In case of business debts or legal actions, members are typically only liable for the amount they invested in the company.


➢ Separate Legal Entity: The LLC is a distinct legal entity from its owners. It can enter into contracts, own assets, and incur liabilities on its own.


➢ Flexibility in Management: Members can choose to manage the company themselves or appoint managers to run day-to-day operations.


➢ Pass-through Taxation: Profits and losses can pass through the company to the individual tax returns of the members. This avoids the double taxation that corporations often face.


➢ Perpetual Existence: An LLC can exist indefinitely, and changes in membership do not typically affect its existence.



(ii) Particulars in the Memorandum of Association:


The Memorandum of Association is a crucial document that outlines the constitution and scope of activities of the company. In the case of an import-export business, it should include, but is not limited to, the following particulars:


➫ Name Clause: The proposed name of the company with the word "Limited" as the last word. Ensure the name is unique and doesn’t infringe on existing trademarks.


➫ Registered Office Clause: The address of the registered office of the company, which is used for official communications.


➫ Object Clause: Clearly define the main objectives and scope of business activities, such as "to carry on the business of import and export of [specific goods or types of products]."


➫ Liability Clause: State that the liability of the members is limited.


Capital Clause: Specify the authorized capital of the company and the division of the capital into shares.


➫ Association and Subscription Clause: Details about the initial members/shareholders and the number of shares each member subscribes to.


➫ Regulation of Internal Management: Outline the rules for the internal management of the company. This may include details about meetings, voting rights, appointment of directors, and so on.


➫ Restrictions on Share Transfers: If there are any restrictions on transferring shares, those should be clearly mentioned.


➫ Winding Up Clause: Specify the procedures to be followed in the event of winding up or dissolution of the company.





QUESTION 1(b)

Q With respect to the nature and classification of companies, distinguish between a registered company and a: (i) Statutory corporation. (ii) Partnership.
A

Solution


i) Registered Company:


A registered company, commonly known as a corporation or a company, is a legal entity that is created by the process of registration under the company law of a particular jurisdiction.

key features:


  1. Separate Legal Entity: A registered company is a distinct legal entity separate from its owners (shareholders). This separation means that the company can own property, enter into contracts, and sue or be sued in its own name.
  2. Limited Liability: One of the main advantages of a registered company is limited liability. Shareholders' liability is typically limited to the amount invested in the company, protecting their personal assets from the company's debts and obligations.
  3. Perpetual Succession: A registered company has perpetual succession, meaning its existence is not affected by changes in ownership. The death or withdrawal of a shareholder does not impact the company's continued existence.
  4. Transferability of Shares: Ownership in a registered company is represented by shares, which are transferable. Shareholders can buy or sell their shares without affecting the company's operations.
  5. Centralized Management: Companies are typically managed by a board of directors elected by the shareholders. Shareholders may not be directly involved in day-to-day operations unless they are also appointed as directors.

ii) Statutory Corporation:


A statutory corporation, also known as a statutory body or government corporation, is a legal entity created by a specific statute or law enacted by the government.


key features:


  1. Government Creation: Statutory corporations are created by an act of the legislature or parliament. They are established for a specific public purpose, such as providing a public service or managing public assets.
  2. Public Ownership: While statutory corporations may have a degree of autonomy, they are typically owned or controlled by the government. The government may appoint the board of directors or have a significant influence on their operations.
  3. Specific Functions: Statutory corporations are established to perform specific functions or deliver particular services in the public interest. Examples include utility companies, educational institutions, or regulatory bodies.
  4. Limited Liability: Similar to registered companies, statutory corporations often have limited liability. However, the extent of liability protection may vary depending on the specific legislation governing the corporation.

iii) Partnership:


A partnership is a business structure where two or more individuals manage and operate a business in accordance with the terms and objectives set out in a Partnership Deed.


key features:


  1. Mutual Agency: Partnerships involve mutual agency, meaning each partner can legally bind the partnership to business agreements. This can lead to joint liability for the actions of other partners.
  2. Unlimited Liability: In a general partnership, partners typically have unlimited personal liability for the debts and obligations of the business. This means personal assets can be used to satisfy business debts.
  3. Flexibility in Management: Partnerships offer flexibility in management. Partners can actively participate in day-to-day operations and decision-making, and the level of involvement can be outlined in the Partnership Deed.
  4. Pass-Through Taxation: Similar to limited liability companies, partnerships often have pass-through taxation. Profits and losses pass through to the individual partners, who report them on their personal tax returns.
  5. Limited Life: Partnerships may have a limited life, and the business may dissolve if a partner leaves or if there are changes in ownership. The continuity of the partnership is not as perpetual as that of a registered company.




QUESTION 1(c)

Q Outline FIVE instances under common law where the veil of incorporation may be lifted
A

Solution


1. Fraud or Illegality:


If a company is used as a vehicle for fraud or illegal activities, the courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold the individuals behind the fraud personally liable.

2. Agency or Alter Ego Doctrine:


When a company is deemed to be the "alter ego" or agent of its shareholders, and the corporate form is used to conceal individual wrongdoing or avoid legal obligations, the courts may lift the veil to hold individuals responsible.


3. Undercapitalization:


If a company is formed with insufficient capital, and it becomes clear that this was done to avoid potential liabilities, the courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders personally liable for the company's debts.


4. Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities:

If a company fails to observe corporate formalities, such as holding regular meetings, keeping proper records, or maintaining a clear separation between personal and corporate finances, the courts may disregard the corporate structure.


5. Group Enterprises or Single Economic Unit:


In cases involving a group of companies or a single economic unit, the courts may lift the corporate veil to treat the group as a single entity, especially when it's necessary to achieve justice or prevent abuse of the corporate form.


6. Prevention of Injustice or Unconscionable Conduct:

If enforcing the corporate structure would lead to injustice or unconscionable conduct, the courts may intervene to prevent such outcomes and may lift the corporate veil.


7. Statutory Grounds:


Some statutes provide specific grounds for lifting the corporate veil. For example, certain environmental, tax, or employment laws may hold individual shareholders personally liable in specific circumstances.


8. Public Interest:


In cases where there is a clear public interest at stake, the courts may disregard the corporate veil to ensure that the public is protected from fraudulent or harmful activities.





QUESTION 2(a)

Q With respect to company meetings, answer the following questions:

(i) Define a “special notice”.

(ii) Highlight TWO circumstances under which a special notice would be required.

(iii) Describe FOUR matters that require to be determined by members through a special resolution.
A

Solution


(i) Define a "special notice":


A "special notice" is a formal communication sent by a member or a group of members to the company's board of directors, indicating their intention to propose a resolution at an upcoming general meeting that requires special attention. The special notice is a mechanism prescribed by company law to ensure that certain significant matters are brought to the attention of the members and the board well in advance of the meeting.

(ii) Highlight circumstances under which a special notice would be required:


A special notice is typically required in the following circumstances:


  1. Removal of Directors: If members wish to propose the removal of a director before the expiration of their term, a special notice is required. This is a safeguard to prevent arbitrary removals and ensures that the members have adequate time to consider the matter.
  2. Appointment of Auditors: If members want to propose the appointment of auditors other than those recommended by the board, a special notice is necessary. This allows for a transparent and fair process in the selection of auditors.
  3. Alteration of Articles of Association: When members want to propose changes to the company's Articles of Association, which is a significant legal document governing the company's internal affairs, a special notice is required.
  4. Resolutions Requiring Special Majority: In some jurisdictions, certain resolutions, such as amendments to the company's constitution or changes to the nature of the business, may require a special majority (usually a higher percentage of votes). In such cases, a special notice is needed.
  5. Other Special Resolutions: Any resolution that is specified by law or the company's Articles of Association as requiring special notice falls under this category.

(iii) Describe matters that require to be determined by members through a special resolution:


Matters that typically require determination by members through a special resolution include:


  1. Alteration of Articles of Association: Fundamental changes to the company's constitution, such as changes to the company name, objects, share capital, or rights attached to shares, often require a special resolution.
  2. Voluntary Winding-Up: The decision to voluntarily wind up the company or approve other significant changes to the company's status may require a special resolution.
  3. Changing the Company's Status: Converting a private company into a public company or altering the company's status in a significant way usually requires a special resolution.
  4. Issuance of Shares with Special Rights: If the company intends to issue shares with special rights that go beyond the ordinary shares, a special resolution may be required.
  5. Approval of Certain Transactions: Some jurisdictions and company laws specify that certain transactions, such as substantial property transactions with directors or members, require approval through a special resolution.




QUESTION 2(b)

Q In the context of Company Directors:

(i) Explain the indoor management rule.

(ii) Identify what constitutes Directors’ remuneration.
A

Solution


(i) Explain the indoor management rule:


The indoor management rule, also known as the Turquand Rule or the Doctrine of Constructive Notice, is a legal principle that protects third parties dealing with a company from the consequences of irregularities within the company's internal affairs. The rule essentially states that outsiders are entitled to assume that the internal procedures and authority within a company have been properly followed.

Key points regarding the indoor management rule:


  1. Protection of Third Parties: The rule primarily serves to protect the interests of third parties, such as creditors, shareholders, and anyone transacting with the company, who may not have access to or knowledge of the company's internal documents and procedures.
  2. Assumption of Regularity: External parties are entitled to assume that the company's internal management and decision-making processes have been regular and validly conducted. They are not required to inquire into the company's internal workings.
  3. Exceptions: While the indoor management rule provides protection, it does not apply in cases of actual notice or where the third party has knowledge of irregularities. If a third party is aware of any irregularities or inconsistencies in the company's internal affairs, they cannot rely on the rule.
  4. Applicability: The rule is particularly relevant in contractual and commercial transactions. For example, if a person enters into a contract with a company, they can assume that the directors have the authority to bind the company, even if there are internal irregularities or breaches of the company's constitution.

(ii) Identify what constitutes Directors’ remuneration:


Directors' remuneration refers to the compensation, financial rewards, or benefits provided to directors of a company for their services and responsibilities. It encompasses various elements, and the specific components may vary based on company policies, shareholder agreements, and legal requirements.


Common elements of directors' remuneration include:


  1. Basic Salary or Fee: This is the fixed amount paid to directors as compensation for their role and responsibilities. It is usually determined by the board of directors or a remuneration committee.
  2. Bonuses and Performance-Related Pay: Directors may receive bonuses or performance-related pay linked to the company's financial performance, achievements of specific targets, or individual performance.
  3. Stock Options and Share Awards: Companies may provide directors with stock options or share awards as part of their remuneration. This aligns the interests of directors with those of shareholders, as it ties their compensation to the company's long-term success.
  4. Benefits and Perquisites: Directors may receive various benefits and perquisites, such as health insurance, retirement benefits, use of company cars, housing allowances, or other allowances and facilities.
  5. Pension Contributions: Companies may contribute to directors' pension plans or provide other retirement benefits as part of their remuneration package.
  6. Non-Executive Director Fees: Non-executive directors, who are not involved in day-to-day operations, may receive fees for attending board meetings and providing strategic guidance.
  7. Committee Fees: Directors serving on specific committees, such as audit or remuneration committees, may receive additional fees for their specialized contributions.
  8. Consultancy Fees: In some cases, directors may provide additional services or consultancy to the company beyond their regular directorial duties, and they may receive fees for such services.




QUESTION 3(a)

Q In relation to company membership:

(i) Describe TWO rules which a company might use to remove from its register of members details of a former member.

(ii) Explain the circumstances under which a court might order rectification of the register of members of a company.

(iii) Explain FOUR disadvantages that a minority shareholder may face in bringing a derivative action
A

Solution


(i) Describe rules which a company might use to remove from its register of members details of a former member:


Companies typically have rules and procedures in place to remove the details of a former member from the register of members. Common rules include:

  1. Resignation or Transfer: If a member voluntarily resigns or transfers their shares to another party, the company updates the register accordingly.
  2. Sale or Transfer of Shares: The company's articles of association may specify the process for transferring shares. Once shares are sold or transferred, the company updates the register to reflect the new member's details.
  3. Death of a Member: In the case of a deceased member, the company removes the deceased person's details from the register upon receiving appropriate documentation and transfers the shares to the heirs or beneficiaries.
  4. Court Order: If a court orders the removal of a former member's details, the company must comply with the court's decision.
  5. Forfeiture of Shares: If the company has the power to forfeit shares due to non-payment or other specified reasons, it may remove the details of the former member from the register after the shares are forfeited.
  6. Compulsory Acquisition: In certain situations, a company may have the power to compulsorily acquire the shares of a member, leading to the removal of that member's details from the register.

(ii) Explain the circumstances under which a court might order rectification of the register of members of a company:


A court may order rectification of the register of members in the following circumstances:

  1. Fraud or Misrepresentation: If there is evidence of fraud or misrepresentation in the entry of a person's name into the register, the court may order rectification to correct the misleading information.
  2. Mistake or Error: Rectification may be ordered if there is a genuine mistake or error in the register that needs correction. This could include typographical errors, miscalculations, or other inadvertent mistakes.
  3. Invalid Transfers: If a transfer of shares is found to be invalid, and the register has been updated based on that invalid transfer, the court may order rectification to restore the correct ownership details.
  4. Court Decision: If a court determines that a person's name was wrongly entered or omitted from the register due to a court decision, it may order rectification to align the register with its ruling.
  5. Breach of Fiduciary Duty: If a company's officers or directors breach their fiduciary duty in maintaining the register, leading to inaccuracies, the court may order rectification.
  6. Equitable Grounds: In some cases, the court may order rectification on equitable grounds to prevent injustice or unfairness, even if there is no strict legal basis for the rectification.

(iii) Explain disadvantages that a minority shareholder may face in bringing a derivative action:


A minority shareholder may face several disadvantages in bringing a derivative action, including:

  1. Costs: Legal proceedings can be expensive, and a minority shareholder may bear the costs of the litigation. If the case is unsuccessful, the shareholder may not recover these costs.
  2. Lack of Control: Minority shareholders may not have sufficient voting power to influence the decisions of the company or the outcome of the derivative action.
  3. Risk of Retaliation: Minority shareholders bringing derivative actions may face the risk of retaliation from the majority shareholders or company management, potentially leading to further disadvantages or marginalization.
  4. Limited Recovery: Even if successful, the recovery obtained through a derivative action may benefit the company as a whole rather than the individual minority shareholder directly.
  5. Procedural Hurdles: Bringing a derivative action often involves legal complexities and procedural hurdles, and minority shareholders may not have the legal expertise or resources to navigate these challenges effectively.
  6. Time-consuming Process: Legal proceedings can be time-consuming, and minority shareholders may find the duration of the litigation to be a significant drawback.
  7. Limited Access to Information: Minority shareholders may face challenges in accessing relevant company information to build a strong case, especially if the majority shareholders or company management control the flow of information.
  8. Legal Restrictions: Some jurisdictions impose legal restrictions on minority shareholders' ability to bring derivative actions, making it difficult for them to pursue legal remedies.




QUESTION 3(b)

Q Describe FIVE responsibilities of a company secretary.
A

Solution


A company secretary plays a crucial role in ensuring that a company complies with legal and regulatory requirements while also facilitating effective communication and coordination within the organization. The responsibilities of a company secretary generally include:

  1. Corporate Governance:

    • Advising the board of directors on governance issues and best practices.
    • Ensuring compliance with corporate governance codes and standards.
    • Organizing and preparing materials for board and committee meetings.
  2. Legal Compliance:

    • Ensuring compliance with company law, regulatory requirements, and other relevant legislation.
    • Filing statutory returns and other legal documents with government authorities.
    • Keeping abreast of changes in laws and regulations that may impact the company.
  3. Board Support and Communication:

    • Coordinating board and committee meetings, including the preparation of agendas and minutes.
    • Facilitating communication between the board, senior management, and shareholders.
    • Providing guidance to directors on their duties and responsibilities.
  4. Record Keeping and Documentation:

    • Maintaining and updating statutory records, including the register of members.
    • Documenting decisions made by the board and ensuring proper record-keeping.
    • Managing the company's official seal and other legal documents.
  5. Shareholder Relations:

    • Managing communications with shareholders, including responding to queries.
    • Organizing and facilitating annual general meetings and other shareholder meetings.
    • Handling share-related matters, such as transfers and issuance.
  6. Risk Management and Compliance:

    • Assisting in the development and implementation of risk management policies.
    • Monitoring compliance with internal policies and procedures.
    • Advising on legal and regulatory risks and proposing mitigation strategies.
  7. Financial Compliance:

    • Ensuring financial records are maintained in compliance with applicable laws.
    • Coordinating with the finance department on financial reporting requirements.
    • Facilitating the audit process and liaising with external auditors.
  8. Training and Development:

    • Keeping directors and employees informed about their legal and regulatory obligations.
    • Providing training on corporate governance and compliance matters.
    • Promoting a culture of ethical conduct and compliance within the organization.
  9. Company Secretarial Practice:

    • Staying informed about best practices in company secretarial work.
    • Providing guidance on the company's constitution and articles of association.
    • Managing the issuance and transfer of shares.
  10. Advisory Role:

    • Offering legal and governance advice to the board and senior management.
    • Participating in strategic decision-making processes.
    • Contributing to the development of corporate policies and procedures.




QUESTION 4(a)

Q The general rule is that an auditor is only liable to the company for professional negligence. Discuss THREE circumstances under which the auditor of a company might be liable to third parties for professional negligence.
A

Solution


The general rule is that an auditor's liability is limited to the company for professional negligence. However, there are circumstances under which an auditor might be found liable to third parties for professional negligence. The liability to third parties is often based on the concept of "duty of care" and is subject to legal principles. Some common circumstances include:

1. Fraud or Collusion:


If the auditor is involved in fraudulent activities or colludes with company officers to present a misleading financial picture, they may be held liable to third parties who rely on the audited financial statements.


2. Foreseen Users:


In some jurisdictions, auditors may owe a duty of care to third parties if it is reasonably foreseeable that these parties will rely on the audited financial statements. For example, creditors, investors, or suppliers may be considered foreseeable users.


3. Statutory Duty to Third Parties:


Some jurisdictions have statutes or case law that explicitly imposes a duty of care on auditors to certain third parties. These statutes may extend liability to parties beyond the company.


4. Negligent Misstatement:


If the auditor makes a negligent misstatement in the audited financial statements that leads to financial loss for a third party, the auditor may be held liable for negligence.


5. Known and Intended Users:


If the auditor is aware that the financial statements are intended for a specific third party, and that party suffers a loss due to the auditor's negligence, the auditor may be held liable.


6. Reliance by Third Parties:


If third parties can demonstrate that they reasonably relied on the audited financial statements and suffered a loss as a result of the auditor's negligence, a court may find the auditor liable.


7. Failure to Detect Fraud or Irregularities:


If the auditor fails to detect material fraud or irregularities in the financial statements, and third parties rely on those statements to their detriment, the auditor may be held liable.


8. Scope of Engagement:


If the auditor undertakes a specific engagement or issues a report with the knowledge that it will be used by third parties, they may assume a duty of care to those third parties.


9. No Privity of Contract:


In some jurisdictions, the lack of a direct contractual relationship between the auditor and a third party does not necessarily preclude the possibility of the auditor being held liable if other legal criteria are met.


10. Negligent Performance of Non-Audit Services:


If the auditor provides non-audit services (e.g., tax advice) and performs them negligently, third parties who rely on that advice may have grounds to claim against the auditor.






QUESTION 4(b)

Q Outline THREE items contained in a company’s auditor report.
A

Solution


An auditor's report is a formal statement included in a company's financial statements that outlines the auditor's opinion on the fairness and accuracy of the financial information. The auditor's report typically consists of several key components. Below is an outline of items contained in a typical company auditor's report:

1. Title:


Introduction with a title indicating it is an "Independent Auditor's Report."


2. Addressee:


Identification of the report's intended recipients, usually the company's shareholders or the board of directors.


3. Opening Paragraph:


A statement confirming that the audit has been conducted in accordance with applicable auditing standards.


4. Scope Paragraph:


Explanation of the scope of the audit, including the specific financial statements audited and the period covered.


5. Statement of Auditor's Responsibility:


A clear statement outlining the auditor's responsibility to express an opinion on the financial statements based on the audit.


6. Statement of Management's Responsibility:


A statement indicating that the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements are the responsibility of the company's management.


7. Description of Audit Process:


A brief overview of the audit procedures performed, including testing of transactions, examination of documents, and assessment of accounting policies.


8. Audit Findings and Assessments:


Presentation of the auditor's findings and assessments, including any material misstatements identified during the audit.


9. Materiality Threshold:


Disclosure of the materiality threshold applied during the audit and any adjustments made for material misstatements.


10. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies:


Reference to and, if necessary, a summary of the significant accounting policies applied by the company.


11. Auditor's Opinion:


The auditor's professional opinion on whether the financial statements present a true and fair view in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. Common types of opinions include unqualified, qualified, adverse, or a disclaimer of opinion.


12. Emphasis of Matter:


Any additional comments or matters that the auditor wishes to highlight, even if the financial statements are unqualified.


13. Other Reporting Responsibilities:


Statements regarding other reporting responsibilities, such as reporting on internal control over financial reporting (if applicable).


14. Auditor's Signature and Date:


The auditor's signature and the date of the report.


15. Auditor's Address:


The auditor's contact information, including the address of the auditing firm.






QUESTION 4(c)

Q Directors are required to prepare a director’s report to accompany the financial statement presented to members.

Highlight FOUR matters captured in a director’s report.
A

Solution


A Director's Report is a document prepared by the directors of a company that accompanies the financial statements and provides additional information about the company's performance, activities, and financial position. The specific matters covered in a Director's Report can vary based on legal requirements and the nature of the business, but typically include the following:

1. Business Review:


Overview of the company's activities and a review of the business environment in which it operates.


2. Financial Performance:


Discussion of the company's financial performance during the reporting period, including key financial indicators, revenue, and profit or loss.


3. Future Outlook:


Forward-looking statements and the directors' assessment of the company's future prospects, risks, and opportunities.


4. Principal Activities:


Description of the company's principal activities and any significant changes in those activities during the reporting period.


5. Dividends:


Declaration and justification of any dividends proposed or declared during the financial year.


6. Risk Management:


Discussion of the company's risk management policies and practices, including identification and mitigation of key risks.


7. Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR):


Disclosure of the company's CSR initiatives and activities, if applicable.


8. Employee Matters:


Information about the company's employees, including the average number of employees, training programs, and any employee share schemes.


9. Environmental Impact:


Discussion of the company's impact on the environment and any measures taken to mitigate environmental risks.


10. Subsidiaries and Associates:


Information about the company's subsidiaries and associates, including changes in their structure or performance.


11. Directors' Interests:


Disclosure of directors' interests in the company, including shareholdings and any conflicts of interest.


12. Directors' Report Approval:


A statement confirming that the directors' report has been approved and signed by the board of directors.


13. Events After the Reporting Period:


Disclosure of significant events or transactions that occurred after the end of the reporting period but before the date of the report.


14. Auditor's Independence Statement:


Confirmation that the auditor has reported directly to the shareholders on the matters required by auditing standards.


15. Corporate Governance:


Information on the company's corporate governance structure and compliance with governance codes.


16. Remuneration Report:


Details of the company's policy on the remuneration of directors and key executives, and disclosure of individual directors' remuneration.






QUESTION 4(d)

Q Identify THREE ways in which the appointment of a Court appointed inspector may be terminated.
A

Solution


The appointment of a court-appointed inspector, often conducted in the context of a company investigation, can be terminated through various means. The specific termination mechanisms may depend on the legal framework under which the inspector was appointed. Here are common ways in which the appointment of a court-appointed inspector may be terminated:

1. Completion of Investigation:


The appointment may be terminated upon completion of the investigation for which the inspector was appointed. Once the inspector has fulfilled the specified scope of work, their role may naturally come to an end.


2. Submission of Report:


Termination may occur upon the submission of the inspector's report to the court. The inspector typically presents findings and recommendations based on the investigation, and the termination follows the conclusion of this reporting phase.


3. Court Order:


The court that appointed the inspector may issue an order to terminate the appointment. This can be based on various factors, such as the completion of the investigation, a change in circumstances, or other legal considerations.


4. Resignation of the Inspector:


The inspector may choose to resign from their appointment for various reasons, such as personal or professional reasons. The court may accept the resignation and terminate the appointment accordingly.


5. Settlement or Resolution:


If the issues leading to the appointment of the inspector are resolved through settlement or other means, the court may terminate the inspector's appointment. This often occurs when parties involved reach an agreement that addresses the underlying concerns.


6. Expiration of Term:


The court order appointing the inspector may specify a term or duration for the appointment. The appointment automatically terminates upon the expiration of this term.


7. Lack of Progress or Need:


If the court determines that the inspector's role is no longer necessary or if there is a lack of progress in the investigation, the court may terminate the appointment.


8. Loss of Qualifications:


If the inspector loses the qualifications or meets conditions required for the appointment, the court may terminate the inspector's role.


9. Challenge to Legitimacy:


If there is a challenge to the legitimacy of the appointment, such as allegations of bias or improper conduct, the court may review and potentially terminate the appointment.


10. Change in Circumstances:


A significant change in circumstances, such as a change in the legal or regulatory framework, may lead to the termination of the inspector's appointment.






QUESTION 5(a)

Q Describe THREE circumstances under which a company is allowed to pay commission on shares.
A

Solution


The payment of commission on shares by a company is a regulated practice, and it must comply with legal provisions and company law. The circumstances under which a company is allowed to pay commission on shares typically include:

1. Authorization in Articles of Association:


The company's Articles of Association must explicitly authorize the payment of commission on shares. This authorization may include specific conditions, limitations, and procedures for paying such commissions.


2. Approval by Shareholders:


The payment of commission on shares often requires approval from the company's shareholders. Shareholders may pass a resolution authorizing the payment, and the resolution must comply with the relevant legal requirements.


3. Percentage Limit:


Legal provisions or regulations may prescribe a maximum percentage or limit on the commission that can be paid on shares. The company must ensure that the commission paid falls within the permissible limits.


4. Conditions for Issuing New Shares:


Companies may be allowed to pay commission on shares issued as part of a new share issue. This is common when the company is raising capital and requires financial intermediaries or brokers to help sell the new shares.


5. Purpose of Issuing Shares:


The payment of commission on shares is often tied to a specific purpose, such as raising capital for business expansion, acquisitions, or other corporate activities. The purpose must be in the best interests of the company.


6. Disclosure in Prospectus:


If the company is issuing shares to the public, the payment of commission on shares should be disclosed in the prospectus. This ensures transparency, and potential investors are informed about the terms of the share issue.


7. Regulatory Compliance:


The company must comply with relevant regulatory requirements and securities laws governing the payment of commission on shares. Regulatory bodies may set guidelines and conditions for such payments.


8. Fair and Reasonable:


The payment of commission on shares should be fair and reasonable. It should not unfairly dilute the value of existing shares or disadvantage existing shareholders.


9. Record Keeping:


Companies must maintain proper records of the commission paid on shares, including details of the recipients and the amounts paid. This is essential for transparency and regulatory compliance.


10. Restrictions on Buy-Back:


In some jurisdictions, companies may be allowed to pay commission on shares when buying back their own shares. The conditions for such buy-backs, including the payment of commission, are usually specified in company law.






QUESTION 5(b)

Q Highlight the circumstances under which a company might decline to register a transfer of shares.
A

Solution


A company may decline to register a transfer of shares under various circumstances. The specific reasons for refusing to register a transfer are typically outlined in the company's Articles of Association and governed by relevant legal provisions. Here are common circumstances under which a company might decline to register a transfer of shares:

1. Incomplete Documentation:


If the documentation accompanying the share transfer is incomplete or not in compliance with the company's requirements, the company may refuse to register the transfer.


2. Breach of Pre-Emptive Rights:


If the company's Articles of Association or shareholder agreements grant existing shareholders pre-emptive rights to purchase additional shares before they are offered to external parties, the company may decline a transfer that violates these rights.


3. Failure to Pay Transfer Fees:


Companies may charge fees for processing share transfers. If the transferor or transferee fails to pay the required transfer fees, the company may decline to register the transfer.


4. Restrictions in Articles of Association:


The Articles of Association may include specific provisions allowing the company to refuse the transfer of shares under certain conditions. Common restrictions include restrictions on transfers to non-members or certain categories of individuals.


5. Unpaid Calls or Debts:


If the transferor has unpaid calls or debts owed to the company, the company may refuse to register the transfer until these financial obligations are settled.


6. Share Lock-In Agreements:


Shareholders may be subject to lock-in agreements that restrict the transfer of shares for a specific period. If a transfer violates such an agreement, the company may decline to register it.


7. Legal Restraints:


Legal or regulatory restrictions may prevent the transfer of shares, such as court orders, regulatory restrictions, or other legal impediments.


8. Forgery or Fraud:


If there is evidence of forgery or fraudulent activity related to the share transfer, the company has the right to decline registration.


9. Dispute Over Ownership:


If there is a dispute over the ownership of the shares or conflicting claims to the same shares, the company may withhold registration until the matter is resolved.


10. Contravention of Statutory Provisions:


If the transfer violates statutory provisions or regulations governing the transfer of shares, the company may refuse to register it to ensure compliance with the law.


11. Failure to Meet Approval Requirements:


Certain transfers, especially those involving special classes of shares or requiring specific approvals, may be declined if the necessary approvals are not obtained.






QUESTION 5(c)

Q Highlight the particulars contained in a company prospectus.
A

Solution


A company prospectus is a formal legal document that provides essential information to potential investors about the company and the securities being offered. The particulars contained in a company prospectus may vary based on the nature of the securities and applicable regulations, but generally, it includes the following key information:

1. Company Overview:


Information about the company's name, registered office, and a brief overview of its business activities.


2. Objects of the Issue:


The specific purposes for which the company is raising capital through the issuance of securities, such as funding expansion, debt repayment, or working capital.


3. Details of the Securities:


Clear information about the type of securities being offered (e.g., shares, debentures, bonds), their terms, and the rights attached to them.


4. Terms of the Issue:


The terms and conditions of the securities being offered, including issue price, face value, and any discounts or premiums.


5. Use of Proceeds:


A breakdown of how the funds raised through the issuance of securities will be utilized by the company.


6. Financial Information:


Historical financial statements, including balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements, providing an overview of the company's financial performance.


7. Management and Promoter Details:


Information about the company's board of directors, key management personnel, and details about promoters, their shareholding, and their involvement in other companies.


8. Risk Factors:


Disclosure of potential risks associated with the company, industry, and the securities being offered. This includes factors that could adversely impact the company's performance.


9. Litigation History:


Disclosure of any pending or threatened legal actions or regulatory proceedings against the company, its directors, or promoters.


10. Industry Overview:


Information about the industry in which the company operates, market trends, competition, and potential future developments.


11. Terms of the Offering:


Details about the duration of the offer, opening and closing dates, procedures for application and payment, and any provisions for the extension or withdrawal of the offer.


12. Credit Rating:


If applicable, the credit rating assigned to the securities by recognized credit rating agencies.


13. Listing Information:


If the securities are proposed to be listed on a stock exchange, details about the stock exchange(s), and the listing process.


14. Material Contracts:


Details of any material contracts or agreements that could have a significant impact on the company's financial position.


15. Statutory and Other Information:


Compliance with statutory requirements, details of the lead manager, registrar, and transfer agent, and other relevant legal and administrative details.


16. Declaration and Undertakings:


Declarations by the company, its directors, and other involved parties regarding the accuracy and completeness of the information provided in the prospectus.






QUESTION 6(a)

Q Highlight FOUR grounds upon which the commissioner of insurance might petition for the winding up of a company
A

Solution


The Commissioner of Insurance may petition for the winding up of a company under various grounds, usually related to concerns about the financial stability, solvency, and proper functioning of the insurance company. Here are some grounds upon which the Commissioner of Insurance might petition for the winding up of a company:

1. Insolvency:


If the insurance company is unable to meet its financial obligations, including the payment of claims, and is deemed insolvent, the Commissioner of Insurance may petition for winding up.


2. Failure to Comply with Regulatory Requirements:


Non-compliance with regulatory requirements, such as failure to maintain the required capital adequacy, submit necessary reports, or adhere to prescribed financial ratios, can be grounds for winding up.


3. Fraudulent Activities:


Discovery of fraudulent activities within the company, including misrepresentation of financial statements, embezzlement, or other fraudulent practices, may lead the Commissioner to petition for winding up.


4. Failure to Remediate Regulatory Concerns:


If the insurance company fails to address regulatory concerns raised by the Commissioner despite warnings and opportunities to rectify issues, winding up may be considered.


5. Endangering Policyholder Interests:


If the financial instability or mismanagement of the company poses a significant risk to the interests of policyholders, the Commissioner may intervene to protect policyholders through the winding-up process.


6. Inability to Pay Debts:


Inability to pay debts as they become due or a clear demonstration that the company is not financially viable may be grounds for winding up.


7. Breach of Statutory Obligations:


Violation of statutory obligations imposed by insurance laws and regulations, including failure to maintain required reserves, may lead to winding up proceedings.


8. Failure to Rectify Deficiencies:


If the Commissioner identifies deficiencies in the company's operations or financial condition and the company fails to take corrective measures within a specified period, winding up may be initiated.


9. Risk to the Stability of the Insurance Market:


The Commissioner may petition for winding up if the continued operation of the insurance company poses a systemic risk to the stability of the insurance market.


10. Compromised Ability to Meet Claims:


If the Commissioner determines that the company's financial condition compromises its ability to meet policyholder claims and obligations, it may seek winding up to safeguard policyholder interests.


11. Public Interest and Consumer Protection:


The Commissioner may consider the broader public interest and the protection of consumers in deciding to petition for winding up, especially if the company's operations are deemed detrimental to the overall market and consumers.






QUESTION 6(b)

Q Highlight SIX powers that a liquidator can exercise without the sanction of the court.
A

Solution


A liquidator, appointed to wind up a company, possesses certain powers that can be exercised without the need for prior court approval. These powers are typically granted by law and are considered inherent to the liquidation process.Below are some powers that a liquidator can exercise without the sanction of the court:

1. Realization of Assets:


The liquidator has the authority to sell, lease, or otherwise realize the assets of the company in order to generate funds for distribution to creditors.


2. Payment of Debts:


Using the funds obtained from the realization of assets, the liquidator can pay the debts and liabilities of the company in accordance with the established order of priority.


3. Compromise with Creditors:


The liquidator may negotiate and enter into compromises or arrangements with creditors, subject to the approval of a committee of creditors or a general meeting of creditors.


4. Distribution of Assets:


After meeting the company's liabilities, the liquidator can distribute the remaining assets among the shareholders or contributors to the company, following the prescribed order of distribution.


5. Summoning Meetings:


The liquidator has the authority to summon and conduct meetings of creditors and contributories for the purpose of providing updates on the liquidation process and seeking approval for certain actions.


6. Investigation and Recovery of Assets:


The liquidator can investigate the affairs of the company, including any transactions that may be deemed voidable or fraudulent. They have the power to take legal action to recover assets for the benefit of creditors.


7. Execution of Documents:


The liquidator can execute necessary documents, contracts, or deeds on behalf of the company in the course of winding up.


8. Appointment of Professional Advisors:


The liquidator can appoint professionals, such as accountants, lawyers, or valuers, to assist in the winding-up process without seeking court approval.


9. Disposal of Unclaimed Assets:


If any assets remain unclaimed by entitled parties after a specified period, the liquidator may dispose of such assets for the benefit of creditors.


10. Filing Reports with Regulatory Authorities:


The liquidator is responsible for filing necessary reports and documents with relevant regulatory authorities to comply with legal requirements.


11. Closing Bank Accounts:


The liquidator has the authority to close the company's bank accounts after settling its financial affairs.






QUESTION 6(c)

Q In the context of foreign companies:

(i) Highlight FOUR particulars contained in a certificate of registration of a foreign company.

(ii) Discuss the options available to a foreign company to establish presence in Kenya.
A

Solution


(i) Particulars contained in a Certificate of Registration of a Foreign Company:


A Certificate of Registration for a foreign company typically includes key information about the company and its authorization to operate within a specific jurisdiction. While the specific details may vary depending on local regulations, common particulars contained in such a certificate may include:

1. Company Name and Registration Number:


The legal name of the foreign company as registered in its home country and the unique registration or identification number assigned.


2. Date of Registration:


The date on which the foreign company was officially registered to operate within the jurisdiction.


3. Legal Form and Governing Law:


The legal structure or form of the company (e.g., corporation, limited liability company) and the governing law under which it operates.


4. Principal Place of Business:


The address of the principal place of business or registered office of the foreign company within the jurisdiction.


5. Nature of Business:


A brief description of the nature of the business activities that the foreign company is authorized to carry out in the jurisdiction.


6. Details of Directors and Officers:


Names, addresses, and roles of the directors, officers, or other authorized representatives of the foreign company.


7. Share Capital and Structure:


Information about the company's share capital, including details about the types of shares, their values, and any restrictions on their transfer.


8. Duration of Registration:


The period for which the foreign company is authorized to operate within the jurisdiction, which may be perpetual or for a specified duration.


9. Details of Registration Authority:


Information about the regulatory or governmental authority responsible for the registration and oversight of foreign companies.


10. Annual Compliance Requirements:


Any requirements or obligations that the foreign company must fulfill annually to maintain its registration status, such as filing annual reports or financial statements.


(ii) Options Available to a Foreign Company to Establish Presence in Kenya:


Foreign companies seeking to establish a presence in Kenya can explore several options, each with its own implications and requirements:


1. Branch Office:


Establishing a branch office allows the foreign company to conduct business in Kenya as an extension of its overseas operations. The branch is subject to local regulations and must register with the relevant authorities.


2. Subsidiary Company:


Creating a subsidiary company involves incorporating a new legal entity in Kenya, distinct from the foreign company. The subsidiary operates independently but is owned or controlled by the foreign parent company.


3. Representative Office:


A representative office serves as a liaison or promotional office and is limited in its activities to marketing, research, and representation. It cannot engage in commercial activities.


4. Joint Venture:


Entering into a joint venture involves partnering with a local entity to create a new business. This allows the foreign company to share risks and benefits with a local partner.


5. Franchising:


The foreign company can expand its presence through franchising, allowing local entrepreneurs to operate under its established brand and business model.


6. Agency or Distributorship:


Establishing a local agency or appointing a distributor enables the foreign company to sell its products or services in Kenya through local intermediaries.


7. Mergers and Acquisitions:


Acquiring or merging with an existing Kenyan company provides a direct entry into the market and access to its established customer base and operations.


8. Technology Transfer Agreements:


The foreign company can enter into agreements to transfer technology, intellectual property, or know-how to a Kenyan entity in exchange for royalties or other considerations.


9. Participation in Government Projects:


Participating in government projects through tenders or partnerships with local entities may provide opportunities for foreign companies, especially in sectors like infrastructure.


10. Compliance with Investment Laws:


Understanding and complying with Kenyan investment laws and regulations is crucial for any foreign company seeking to establish a presence, including obtaining necessary approvals and permits.


11. Trade Associations and Chambers of Commerce:


Joining local trade associations and chambers of commerce can facilitate networking, provide market insights, and aid in navigating the local business environment.






QUESTION 7(a)

Q Highlight FIVE forms of corporate restructuring.
A

Solution


Corporate restructuring refers to the significant changes made to the structure or operations of a company, often with the aim of improving its financial performance, strategic positioning, or overall efficiency. There are various forms of corporate restructuring, each serving different purposes. Below are some common forms:

1. Mergers:


A merger occurs when two or more companies combine to form a new entity. The purpose is to enhance market presence, achieve economies of scale, and improve competitiveness.


2. Acquisitions:


An acquisition involves one company acquiring another, resulting in the acquired company becoming a part of the acquiring company. The purpose is to gain access to new markets, acquire key assets, or eliminate competitors.


3. Divestitures:


Divestiture involves the sale, closure, or spin-off of a business unit or subsidiary by a company. The purpose is to focus on core business activities, improve financial performance, or raise capital.


4. Demergers or Spin-offs:


A demerger or spin-off involves the separation of a business unit into a standalone entity. The purpose is to create independent companies, each with a distinct focus and strategic direction.


5. Joint Ventures:


A joint venture is a partnership between two or more companies to undertake a specific business project or activity. The purpose is to share risks, access new markets, and leverage complementary skills.


6. Restructuring of Debt:


Debt restructuring involves modifying the terms of a company's debt obligations to alleviate financial distress. The purpose is to improve liquidity, reduce debt burden, and avoid bankruptcy.


7. Financial Restructuring:


Financial restructuring involves changing the capital structure, such as issuing new equity or repurchasing shares. The purpose is to enhance financial stability, optimize capital, and improve shareholder value.


8. Operational Restructuring:


Operational restructuring focuses on improving the efficiency and effectiveness of a company's operations. The purpose is to streamline processes, reduce costs, and enhance overall operational performance.


9. Asset Sales or Leasebacks:


Asset sales involve selling assets, followed by leasing them back from the buyer. The purpose is to unlock capital tied in assets, improve liquidity, and maintain operational control.


10. Rightsizing or Downsizing:


Rightsizing or downsizing involves reducing the size of the workforce or operations to align with the company's strategic goals. The purpose is to improve cost efficiency, respond to market changes, and refocus on core activities.


11. Leveraged Buyouts (LBO):


A leveraged buyout occurs when a company is acquired using a significant amount of borrowed money. The purpose is to facilitate acquisitions, improve efficiency, and enhance shareholder value.


12. Equity Carve-Outs:


Equity carve-outs involve the sale of a minority stake in a subsidiary through an initial public offering (IPO). The purpose is to unlock value, raise capital, and create a separate market valuation for the subsidiary.


13. Recapitalization:


Recapitalization involves changing the mix of a company's debt and equity to achieve specific financial goals. The purpose is to balance the capital structure, improve financial flexibility, and optimize the cost of capital.


14. Privatization:


Privatization occurs when a government-owned or public company is transferred to private ownership. The purpose is to attract private investment, improve efficiency, and reduce government involvement in business.






QUESTION 7(b)

Q In the context of debt capital, state FIVE advantages of a trust deed.
A

Solution


In the context of debt capital, a trust deed is a legal document that outlines the terms and conditions of a debt arrangement, typically associated with bonds or other debt securities. The trust deed serves as a contract between the issuer of the debt and the trustee representing the interests of the bondholders. Some advantages of a trust deed include the following:

  1. Clear Terms and Conditions: A trust deed provides a clear and detailed set of terms and conditions governing the debt arrangement. This clarity helps in avoiding misunderstandings between the issuer and the bondholders.
  2. Protection for Bondholders:
    • Security and Collateral: Trust deeds often specify the assets or collateral that secure the debt. This provides a level of protection for bondholders in case of default, as the specified assets can be used to satisfy the debt obligation.
    • Covenants and Restrictions: The trust deed may include covenants that impose certain restrictions on the issuer's actions, protecting the interests of bondholders and ensuring sound financial management.
  3. Legal Enforceability: Trust deeds are legally binding documents, making the terms and conditions enforceable by law. Bondholders can take legal action if the issuer fails to meet its obligations, providing a mechanism for recourse.
  4. Transparency: Trust deeds enhance transparency by outlining the rights, obligations, and responsibilities of both the issuer and the bondholders. This transparency fosters confidence among investors and promotes a clear understanding of the debt structure.
  5. Flexibility in Terms: Trust deeds can be tailored to meet the specific needs and preferences of the parties involved. This flexibility allows for customization of terms such as interest rates, maturity dates, and redemption provisions.
  6. Establishment of Trustee: The appointment of a trustee is a key feature of a trust deed. The trustee acts as a fiduciary, representing the interests of the bondholders. This independent oversight ensures that the rights of bondholders are protected.
  7. Defined Default Events: The trust deed typically outlines specific events that would constitute a default. This clarity helps bondholders identify instances where the issuer has failed to meet its obligations, triggering potential remedies.
  8. Ease of Transferability: Trust deeds can include provisions for the transferability of bonds, allowing bondholders to sell or transfer their securities in the secondary market. This liquidity can be attractive to investors.
  9. Facilitation of Debt Issuance: Having a trust deed in place facilitates the issuance of debt securities. Investors may be more willing to participate in a well-structured debt offering with clear terms and protections.
  10. Early Warning System:
    • Reporting Requirements: Trust deeds often include reporting requirements, mandating that issuers provide regular financial updates to bondholders. This serves as an early warning system, allowing investors to monitor the issuer's financial health.
  11. Market Credibility: Trust deeds contribute to the overall credibility of the issuer in the financial markets. A well-drafted trust deed signals a commitment to transparency, investor protection, and adherence to sound financial practices.




QUESTION 7(c)

Q Highlight the documents that a liquidator must lodge with the registrar of companies when making an application for voluntary winding up of a company
A

Solution


When a liquidator is making an application for the voluntary winding up of a company, several documents must be lodged with the registrar of companies. Here's a list highlighting some of the key documents:

  1. Declaration of Solvency: A document where the directors declare that the company is solvent and can pay its debts in full within a specified period, usually 12 months.
  2. Special Resolution: A resolution passed by the shareholders of the company approving the voluntary winding up and appointing the liquidator(s).
  3. Notice of Appointment: A notice specifying the date of the shareholders' meeting where the special resolution was passed and the appointment of the liquidator(s).
  4. Consent of the Liquidator: A written consent from the appointed liquidator(s) to act in that capacity.
  5. Director's Report: A report from the directors providing details about the company's affairs, assets, and liabilities, supporting the declaration of solvency.
  6. Statement of Affairs: A statement prepared by the directors providing a snapshot of the company's financial position at a specific date before the commencement of winding up.
  7. Proxy Form: If applicable, a form allowing a shareholder to appoint a proxy to attend and vote at the meeting on their behalf.
  8. Minutes of the Meeting: Minutes documenting the proceedings of the shareholders' meeting where the special resolution was passed.
  9. Form for Lodging Documents: A specific form prescribed by the registrar of companies for lodging the necessary documents related to the voluntary winding up.
  10. Notice of Appointment of Liquidator: A formal notice indicating the appointment of the liquidator(s) and providing relevant details.
  11. Notification to Creditors: In some jurisdictions, a notice or circular sent to creditors informing them of the company's voluntary winding up.
  12. Any Other Required Documentation: Depending on the jurisdiction, additional documents or forms as required by the relevant company law.




QUESTION 7(d)

Q With respect to company administration, highlight FIVE powers exercised by an administrator appointed by the court.
A

Solution


When an administrator is appointed by the court to manage the affairs of a company, they are granted certain powers to fulfill their duties effectively. The powers exercised by an administrator appointed by the court typically include:

1. Decision-Making Authority:


The administrator has the authority to make decisions on behalf of the company. This may include decisions related to the company's business operations, financial matters, and restructuring initiatives.


2. Financial Management:


The administrator has the power to manage the company's finances during the administration process. This includes overseeing the company's accounts, financial transactions, and budgeting.


3. Negotiation and Contractual Powers:


The administrator has the ability to negotiate and enter into contracts on behalf of the company. This includes negotiating with creditors, suppliers, and other stakeholders.


4. Sale of Assets:


The administrator can sell or dispose of the company's assets as part of the restructuring or liquidation process. This may involve selling assets to repay creditors or to fund ongoing operations.


5. Employee Management:


The administrator has the authority to make decisions regarding the employment status of the company's workforce. This includes hiring, firing, and making changes to employment contracts.


6. Legal Proceedings:


The administrator may initiate or defend legal proceedings on behalf of the company. This can include actions against third parties, such as pursuing claims or defending against lawsuits.


7. Implementation of Restructuring Plans:


If the goal of administration is to restructure the company, the administrator has the power to develop and implement restructuring plans. This may involve negotiating with creditors, changing the company's structure, or proposing a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA).


8. Communication with Creditors and Shareholders:


The administrator has the responsibility to communicate with creditors and shareholders regarding the company's financial status, the administration process, and any proposed plans for the future.


9. Investigation Powers:


The administrator has the authority to investigate the company's financial affairs and management. This includes reviewing financial records, transactions, and other relevant documents.


10. Reporting Obligations:


The administrator is required to provide regular reports to the court, creditors, and other stakeholders. These reports outline the progress of the administration, financial status, and any proposed actions.


11. Decision on the Company's Future:


The administrator has the authority to determine the future of the company, whether it involves continuing as a going concern, entering into a CVA, or recommending liquidation.






Comments on CPA past papers with answers:

New Unlock your potential with focused revision and soar towards success
Pass Kasneb Certification Exams Easily

Comments on:

CPA past papers with answers