Guaranteed

95.5% Pass Rate

CPA
Intermediate Leval
Company Law December 2022
Suggested Solutions

Company Law
Revision Kit

QUESTION 1a

Q Highlight FIVE rules relating to the naming of companies.
A

Solution


Rules for Naming Companies


  1. Distinctiveness: The name should be distinctive, avoiding close resemblance to existing company names.
  2. No Misleading Elements: The name should accurately represent the business without misleading information.
  3. Legal Compliance: Ensure compliance with regulations set by the relevant business registrar or authority.
  4. Avoid Prohibited or Offensive Terms: Exclude terms that are prohibited or considered offensive.
  5. Use of Corporate Designators: Include appropriate corporate designators based on the company's legal structure.
  6. Approval by Business Registrar: Obtain approval for the proposed name from the business registrar or relevant authority.
  7. No Violation of Trademarks: Ensure the name does not infringe on existing trademarks through a thorough search.
  8. Avoid Generic Terms: Choose a unique and specific name to create a strong brand identity.
  9. Geographical Restrictions: Be aware of restrictions on using geographical names in certain jurisdictions.
  10. No Undesirable Associations: Avoid creating undesirable associations or implying a false connection with government entities.
  11. Use of Acronyms: If using acronyms, ensure they are meaningful and not misleading.
  12. Renewal and Updates: Stay aware of renewal requirements and keep the registered name updated with relevant authorities.




QUESTION 1(b)

Q Describe the effect of the principle elucidated by Lord MacNaghten in the case of Salomon-V-Salomon.
A

Solution


The principle elucidated by Lord MacNaghten in the case of Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd. is fundamental to the concept of corporate law and has a profound effect on the legal status of a company and its members. The case, decided in the House of Lords in 1897, established the separate legal personality of a company and is a cornerstone of company law principles.

Lord MacNaghten's principle, as outlined in the Salomon case, can be summarized as follows:

Separate Legal Personality:

The key effect of Lord MacNaghten's principle is the recognition of a company as a separate legal entity distinct from its shareholders or members. This means that once a company is incorporated, it becomes an independent legal person with its rights, liabilities, and existence separate from those of its owners.

Limited Liability:

The principle reinforces the concept of limited liability for shareholders. Shareholders in a limited liability company are generally not personally liable for the company's debts beyond the amount invested in the company. This limitation of liability encourages investment in businesses and facilitates risk-taking without exposing shareholders to personal financial ruin.

Corporate Veil:

Lord MacNaghten's principle also introduces the notion of the "corporate veil," which is a legal concept that separates the rights and responsibilities of the company from those of its shareholders. The corporate veil protects shareholders from being held personally liable for the company's obligations, and it is only in exceptional circumstances that the veil may be lifted by the courts.

Perpetual Succession:

The separate legal personality of a company, as emphasized by Lord MacNaghten, enables the company to enjoy perpetual succession. Regardless of changes in ownership (transfer of shares) or changes in management, the company continues to exist as a legal entity.

Capacity to Sue and be Sued:

As a separate legal entity, a company has the capacity to enter into contracts, own property, sue, and be sued in its own name. This legal capacity enhances the efficiency and practicality of conducting business activities.

Impact on Corporate Law:

The Salomon case's principle has had a profound and lasting impact on corporate law worldwide. It provides a clear framework for the legal treatment of companies, allowing them to function as distinct entities with their own legal rights and obligations.

While the principle offers numerous advantages, it also raises ethical and legal considerations, such as the potential for abuse of the corporate form (e.g., for fraudulent purposes). However, the principle remains a fundamental aspect of corporate law and continues to shape the legal landscape for companies globally.




QUESTION 1(c)

Q Explain the difference between a “company limited by shares” and a “company limited by guarantee.”
A

Solution


Difference: Company Limited by Shares vs. Company Limited by Guarantee


Company Limited by Shares:


  1. Ownership and Capital: Determined by the number of shares held by each member.
  2. Liability of Members: Limited to the amount unpaid on their shares.
  3. Profit Distribution: Linked to the number and value of shares held.
  4. Common Structure: Used for private and public companies, especially those seeking investment through share sales.
  5. Flexibility in Membership Transfer: Shares can be freely transferred between members, subject to any restrictions.

Company Limited by Guarantee:


  1. Capital and Members' Guarantee: Members do not hold shares; instead, they provide a guarantee to contribute a specific amount in the event of liquidation.
  2. Liability of Members: Limited to the guaranteed amount they undertake to contribute.
  3. Non-Profit Organizations: Often used for non-profit organizations, charities, or entities focused on missions rather than profits.
  4. No Share Capital or Dividends: No shares, no share capital, and members do not receive dividends.
  5. Membership Stability: Membership transfer is more controlled and subject to the company's articles of association.
  6. Charitable Status: Commonly chosen by organizations seeking charitable status.




QUESTION 1(d)

Q Identify FOUR features of an unlimited company.
A

Solution


Features of an Unlimited Company


  • Unlimited Liability: Members have unlimited personal liability for the company's debts and obligations.
  • No Liability Limitation: Unlike limited companies, there is no restriction on the extent of members' liability.
  • Personal Responsibility: Members can be personally responsible for settling the company's debts using their personal assets.
  • Less Common: Unlimited companies are less common than limited companies and are often used for specific purposes.
  • Flexibility: May provide greater flexibility in certain aspects of company management and decision-making.
  • No Share Capital Requirement: There may be no requirement to issue shares or have a specified share capital.
  • Private or Public: Can be formed as a private or public company, depending on the company's structure and objectives.
  • Continuity of Existence: The company continues to exist despite changes in membership or management.
  • Less Stringent Reporting Requirements: May have less stringent reporting requirements compared to some other company types.
  • Legal Autonomy: Enjoys a degree of legal autonomy but lacks the limited liability protection provided by other structures.




QUESTION 2(a)

Q The articles of association form the framework within which the company and its members relate. Highlight FIVE limitations that must be observed when altering the articles of a company.
A

Solution


Limitations on Altering Articles of a Company


  1. Statutory Constraints: Alterations must comply with statutory requirements of the jurisdiction.
  2. Shareholder Approval: Significant changes require approval by a special resolution of shareholders.
  3. Rights of Minority Shareholders: Alterations should not unfairly prejudice the rights of minority shareholders.
  4. Object Clause Restrictions: Changes to the object clause may be restricted and may require regulatory approval.
  5. Ultra Vires Principle: Alterations must not result in actions beyond the legal powers of the company.
  6. Unlawful or Unethical Changes: Amendments should not result in unlawful or unethical activities.
  7. Breach of Contract: Alterations should not breach contractual obligations, including agreements with third parties.
  8. Creditors' Interests: Changes should not unfairly prejudice the interests of creditors.
  9. Procedure and Formalities: The prescribed procedure and formalities must be strictly followed.
  10. Regulatory Approval: Some changes may require approval from regulatory bodies or authorities.
  11. Public Disclosure: Certain changes may require public disclosure for transparency.
  12. Rights Attached to Classes of Shares: Consideration must be given to the rights attached to different classes of shares.




QUESTION 2(b)

Q In relation to corporate restructuring:

(i) Define amalgamation as a corporate restructuring strategy.

(ii) Highlight THREE elements of corporate restructuring.
A

Solution


Corporate Restructuring and Amalgamation


(i) Define Amalgamation as a Corporate Restructuring Strategy:


Amalgamation in corporate restructuring refers to the process of combining two or more companies into a single entity. It involves the consolidation of assets, liabilities, and operations of the merging companies to form a new, integrated organization. Amalgamation is often pursued for strategic reasons, such as achieving synergies, expanding market presence, or improving operational efficiency.

(ii) Highlight Elements of Corporate Restructuring:


  1. Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A): Involves combining two companies (merger) or one company acquiring another (acquisition).
  2. Divestitures: Involves selling off or spinning off certain business units or assets to streamline operations.
  3. Restructuring of Debt: Involves modifying the financial structure, often to reduce debt and improve financial health.
  4. Joint Ventures: Collaboration between two or more companies for a specific project or business activity.
  5. Spin-offs: Creation of a new, independent company by separating a division or business segment from the existing company.
  6. Strategic Alliances: Collaborative agreements between companies to pursue mutual benefits without forming a new entity.
  7. Capital Restructuring: Involves changes to the company's capital structure, such as share buybacks, stock splits, or issuing new securities.
  8. Business Process Reengineering (BPR): Redesigning and optimizing business processes to enhance efficiency and productivity.
  9. Outsourcing and Insourcing: Involves contracting out certain functions (outsourcing) or bringing them in-house (insourcing).
  10. Change in Corporate Governance: Alterations in the structure and functioning of the company's board and governance practices.




QUESTION 2(c)

Q With specific reference to company secretaries:

(i) Identify the circumstance under which a private company is required to have a company secretary.

(ii) Describe the ways in which a private company that does not have a company secretary undertakes service of documents and authorises matters that require a company secretary.
A

Solution


Company Secretaries in Private Companies


(i) Circumstances Requiring a Company Secretary:


A private company is required to have a company secretary under the following circumstances:

  1. Statutory Requirement: In some jurisdictions, company law mandates that a private company must appoint a company secretary.
  2. Constitutional Requirement: The company's articles of association may specify the appointment of a company secretary.
  3. Corporate Governance Code: Compliance with corporate governance codes or regulatory guidelines that recommend or require the appointment of a company secretary.
  4. Director's Resolution: A director's resolution may mandate the appointment of a company secretary as a corporate decision.

(ii) Private Company without a Company Secretary:


If a private company does not have a company secretary, it may undertake service of documents and authorize matters through alternative methods:


  1. Director's Authority: Directors of the company may assume the responsibilities typically handled by a company secretary, including authorizing documents and managing administrative tasks.
  2. Appointment of an Authorized Officer: The company may appoint an authorized officer or designate an existing employee to handle the tasks that would otherwise be performed by a company secretary.
  3. Use of Electronic Means: Documents may be served and authorized electronically, adhering to legal and regulatory requirements for electronic communication.
  4. Outsourcing Services: The company may engage external service providers or professionals to handle specific tasks, such as legal documentation and compliance matters.
  5. Director's Meeting Resolutions: Important decisions may be made through resolutions passed during director's meetings, with directors collectively undertaking the responsibilities that would be handled by a company secretary.




QUESTION 3(a)

Q Describe SEVEN reasons why a shareholder’s membership in a company might be terminated.
A

Solution


Termination of Shareholder Membership


Shareholder membership in a company might be terminated for various reasons, including:

  1. Voluntary Resignation: Shareholders may choose to resign voluntarily by submitting a resignation notice to the company.
  2. Sale of Shares: Shareholders may sell or transfer their shares to another party, resulting in a change of ownership and termination of their membership.
  3. Death: In the case of an individual shareholder, their membership may terminate upon death. Shares may pass to heirs or beneficiaries based on estate planning or legal provisions.
  4. Bankruptcy or Insolvency: If a shareholder becomes bankrupt or insolvent, it may lead to the termination of their membership, subject to legal and regulatory provisions.
  5. Breach of Shareholder Agreement: Termination may occur if a shareholder violates terms outlined in the company's shareholder agreement, such as non-compliance with voting rights or restrictions on share transfer.
  6. Failure to Pay Calls: If a shareholder fails to pay calls on shares as required by the company, it may lead to termination of membership or forfeiture of shares.
  7. Judicial Order: In some cases, a court order may result in the termination of a shareholder's membership, such as in cases of legal disputes or violations of company law.
  8. Expiry of Time Limit: If a shareholder's membership is subject to a time limit or specific conditions and these are not met, their membership may be terminated.
  9. Mutual Agreement: Shareholders and the company may mutually agree to terminate membership for strategic or business reasons.
  10. Merger or Acquisition: In the event of a merger or acquisition, the structure of the company may change, leading to the termination of existing memberships or the issuance of new shares.




QUESTION 3(b)

Q Highlight THREE items that form the content of a members’ register in a company.
A

Solution


Members' Register Content


The members' register in a company typically includes the following items:

  • Name of Members: Full names of all individuals or corporate entities holding shares in the company.
  • Address of Members: Residential or business addresses of individual members or the registered office for corporate members.
  • Contact Details: Contact information such as phone numbers and email addresses of members.
  • Shareholding Details: Number and class of shares held by each member, along with details of any transfers or changes in ownership.
  • Date of Becoming a Member: The date on which each member became a shareholder in the company.
  • Share Certificate Numbers: Reference numbers associated with the share certificates issued to members.
  • Share Allotment Details: Information about the allotment of shares to members, including any conditions or restrictions.
  • Share Transfer Details: Record of any transfers of shares between members, including the date and parties involved.
  • Special Resolutions: Notation of any special resolutions related to membership passed by the company.
  • Consents and Agreements: Documentation of consents, agreements, or restrictions related to membership, if any.
  • Date of Ceasing Membership: The date on which a member ceases to be a shareholder, including reasons for termination if applicable.
  • Proxy Voting Details: Records of proxy votes exercised by members during company meetings, if relevant.
  • Record of Communications: Documentation of official communications sent to members, such as notices, reports, or dividend declarations.




QUESTION 3(c)

Q Brian is a preference shareholder in Duniani Company limited. He is entitled to a dividend of 11%. The company has however been suffering losses and has passed a resolution in a general meeting to reduce the dividends on preference shares to 7%.

Advise Brian on:

(i) His rights as a preference shareholder.

(ii) Whether the company can vary the dividends he may be given.
A

Solution


Advice to Preference Shareholder - Brian


(i) Rights as a Preference Shareholder:


Brian, as a preference shareholder, typically has the following rights:

  • Fixed Dividend: The right to receive a fixed dividend rate, in this case, 11%, before any dividends are paid to ordinary shareholders.
  • Priority in Liquidation: In the event of the company's liquidation, preference shareholders usually have a priority claim on the company's assets over ordinary shareholders.
  • No Voting Rights: Preference shareholders may not have voting rights in certain matters, depending on the company's constitution.
  • Contractual Rights: Rights specified in the terms of the preference shares, which are outlined in the company's articles of association or a separate shareholders' agreement.
  • Redemption Rights: If applicable, the right to have their shares redeemed by the company after a specified period or under certain conditions.

(ii) Variation of Dividends:


The company's ability to vary the dividends on preference shares depends on the terms specified in the articles of association or any relevant contractual agreements. In this case:


The company has passed a resolution in a general meeting to reduce the dividends on preference shares to 7%. It's important for Brian to review the terms of the preference shares, as outlined in the company's constitution or any agreements related to the issuance of preference shares.


If the articles or agreements allow for the variation of dividends, the company may have the legal right to make such changes. However, if the variation is not in accordance with the agreed terms or if it unfairly prejudices preference shareholders, Brian may have grounds to challenge the decision.


Brian should consider seeking legal advice to understand his specific rights and options based on the company's documents and relevant corporate laws.





QUESTION 4(a)

Q Describe the general contents of a company’s annual return.
A

Solution


Contents of a Company's Annual Return


The annual return of a company typically includes the following general contents:

  • Company Information: Name, registration number, and registered office address of the company.
  • Financial Year: The financial period covered by the annual return, indicating the start and end dates.
  • Principal Activities: Description of the principal business activities conducted by the company during the financial year.
  • Share Capital: Details of the company's share capital structure, including the types of shares issued and any changes during the year.
  • Shareholders: Information on shareholders, including their names, addresses, and the number of shares held.
  • Directors: Names, addresses, and details of the company's directors, including any changes during the year.
  • Company Secretary: Details of the company secretary, if applicable, and any changes in this position.
  • Registered Charges: Information on any charges or mortgages registered against the company's assets.
  • Financial Statements: A summary of the company's financial performance, including the balance sheet, profit and loss statement, and cash flow statement.
  • Statutory Declarations: Declarations confirming compliance with statutory requirements and regulations.
  • Annual Accounts: Copies of the company's audited financial statements, including the auditor's report.
  • Declaration of Compliance: A declaration by the directors confirming compliance with legal requirements and the accuracy of the information provided.
  • Date of Annual General Meeting (AGM): The date on which the annual general meeting is scheduled to be held or has been held.
  • Signature: Signatures of authorized officers, such as directors or company secretaries, certifying the accuracy of the annual return.




QUESTION 4(b)

Q Explain the following types of share capital:

(i) Paid-Up Capital.

(ii) Issued Share Capital.
A

Solution


Types of Share Capital


(i) Paid-Up Capital:


Paid-Up Capital refers to the portion of the company's authorized share capital that shareholders have fully paid for. When a company issues shares to investors, they are required to make payments for the shares they subscribe to. The amount received by the company from shareholders in exchange for the shares constitutes the paid-up capital. It represents the actual funds that the company has received and can utilize for its operations, investments, or other financial needs.

Example: If a company issues 1,000 shares with a face value of Ksh.10 each, and shareholders have paid the full amount for 800 shares, the paid-up capital would be Ksh.8,000 (800 shares x Ksh.10).


(ii) Issued Share Capital:


Issued Share Capital refers to the total value of shares that a company has issued to shareholders, whether fully paid or not. It includes both the paid-up capital (the amount paid by shareholders) and the unpaid or partly paid capital. The issued share capital represents the company's commitment to allocate a specific number of shares to investors. While all issued shares contribute to the issued share capital, the paid-up capital is the subset of issued share capital for which payment has been received.


Example: If a company has issued 1,000 shares at Ksh.10 each but shareholders have only paid for 800 shares, the issued share capital would be Ksh.10,000 (1,000 shares x Ksh.10), and the paid-up capital would be Ksh.8,000.


Summary,


While issued share capital represents the total value of shares allocated by the company, paid-up capital specifically refers to the portion for which shareholders have made full payments.





QUESTION 4(c)

Q Summarise the following in relation to company administration:

(i) THREE objectives of administration.

(ii) THREE persons who are entitled to make an application to the Court for an administration order.

(iii) Highlight FOUR powers exercised by an administrator appointed by the Court.
A

Solution


Company Administration Summary


(i) Objectives of Administration:


The objectives of company administration include:

  1. Rescue and Continuation: To rescue the company from insolvency and allow it to continue trading.
  2. Maximization of Asset Value: Maximizing the value of the company's assets for the benefit of creditors.
  3. Fair Distribution: Ensuring a fair distribution of assets among creditors.
  4. Avoiding Liquidation: Seeking alternatives to liquidation and promoting the survival of the business.
  5. Debt Restructuring: Facilitating the restructuring of the company's debts for financial stability.

(ii) Persons Entitled to Make an Application for an Administration Order:


Persons who are entitled to make an application to the Court for an administration order include:


  1. Company Directors: Directors of the company.
  2. Company Shareholders: Shareholders or a majority of shareholders.
  3. Company Creditors: Creditors of the company, including those with a qualifying floating charge.
  4. Administrator: An administrator already appointed by the Court.

(iii) Powers Exercised by an Administrator Appointed by the Court:


An administrator appointed by the Court has the following powers:


  1. Management and Control: Takes control of the company's management and operations.
  2. Decision-Making: Makes decisions on behalf of the company, aiming to achieve administration objectives.
  3. Asset Realization: Has the power to sell or realize the company's assets for the benefit of creditors.
  4. Debt Repayment Plan: Formulates a debt repayment plan for approval by creditors and the Court.
  5. Report to Creditors: Provides regular reports to creditors and the Court on the progress of administration.




QUESTION 5(a)

Q In Re Yorkshire Wool Combers Association Limited, a floating charge is described as one that hovers over the assets of the company as compared to a fixed charge. With reference to the above statement:

(i) Describe THREE circumstances that will cause the crystallisation of a floating charge.

(ii) Outline TWO characteristics of a fixed charge.
A

Solution


Floating Charge and Fixed Charge


(i) Circumstances causing the Crystallisation of a Floating Charge:


A floating charge may crystallize, converting into a fixed charge, under the following circumstances:

  1. Default on Loan Agreement: If the company defaults on the terms of a loan agreement, the floating charge may crystallize, giving the lender more control over the charged assets.
  2. Insolvency: Upon the occurrence of insolvency or a specified event, the floating charge may crystallize, and the assets become fixed, allowing for their realization to satisfy debts.
  3. Notice by Chargeholder: The chargeholder may issue a notice to crystallize the floating charge, often as a protective measure or in response to the company's financial instability.
  4. Specific Event Trigger: The loan agreement or charge documentation may specify certain events, such as a change in ownership or a breach of covenants, leading to the crystallization of the floating charge.

(ii) Characteristics of a Fixed Charge:


A fixed charge possesses the following characteristics:


  1. Specific Assets: A fixed charge is attached to specific identified assets of the company, providing a higher level of security to the lender.
  2. Control and Possession: The chargeholder often gains control or possession of the charged assets, restricting the company's ability to deal with those assets without the lender's consent.
  3. Permanent and Unchanging: Unlike a floating charge, a fixed charge is permanent and remains unchanged unless explicitly released by the chargeholder.
  4. Priority in Liquidation: In the event of insolvency, the holder of a fixed charge has a higher claim on the specific assets covered by the charge compared to other creditors.




QUESTION 5(b)

Q Madax Transporters Limited registered a charge on its fleet of motor vehicles in favour of Kopesha Bank to secure a borrowing of Kenya Shillings Fifty Million (Sh. 50,000,000). Madax Transporters Limited has defaulted on the loan repayment.

Outline FOUR options available to Kopesha Bank as the chargee.
A

Solution


Options for Chargee (Kopesha Bank) in Case of Default


Kopesha Bank, as the chargee, has several options available in response to the default by Madax Transporters Limited:

  1. Enforce the Security Interest: Kopesha Bank can enforce its security interest by taking possession of the fleet of motor vehicles that are the subject of the charge. This allows the bank to sell or realize the value of the assets to recover the outstanding loan amount.
  2. Public Auction or Private Sale: After taking possession, the bank may choose to sell the motor vehicles through a public auction or a private sale. The proceeds from the sale will be used to settle the outstanding debt.
  3. Appoint a Receiver: Kopesha Bank may opt to appoint a receiver to manage and sell the charged assets on its behalf. The receiver acts in the best interest of the bank to recover the loan amount.
  4. Negotiate a Settlement: The bank could enter into negotiations with Madax Transporters Limited to reach a settlement or restructuring agreement. This may involve modifying the terms of the loan or agreeing on a repayment plan.
  5. File a Lawsuit: Kopesha Bank has the legal right to file a lawsuit against Madax Transporters Limited to recover the outstanding debt. The court may issue judgments or orders to facilitate the repayment process.
  6. Debt Recovery Agencies: The bank may engage debt recovery agencies to pursue the debt on its behalf. These agencies specialize in recovering outstanding amounts and may employ various strategies to compel payment.




QUESTION 5(c)

Q Highlight SIX instances when one person can form quorum in a company meeting.
A

Solution


Instances of Quorum in Company Meetings


In various scenarios, one person may be sufficient to form a quorum in a company meeting. These instances include:

  • Single-Member Company: In a single-member company, where there is only one shareholder, that shareholder constitutes the entire quorum for meetings.
  • Unanimous Consent: Some jurisdictions allow for meetings to proceed with unanimous consent, where all members agree to conduct the meeting and make decisions without the need for a formal quorum.
  • Specific Articles or Bylaws: The company's articles of association or bylaws may contain provisions allowing for a reduced quorum or specifying circumstances where a single member can form a quorum.
  • Emergency Situations: In emergency situations where prompt decision-making is crucial, a single member or a specified individual may be authorized to make decisions on behalf of the company.
  • Proxy Representation: Some jurisdictions permit the use of proxies, allowing a single member to represent multiple shareholders and form a quorum.
  • Virtual Meetings: In the era of virtual meetings, where allowed by regulations, a single member participating remotely may constitute a valid quorum.
  • Statutory Exemptions: Certain statutory frameworks may provide exemptions or alternative quorum requirements for specific types of companies or meetings.
  • Deemed Unanimity: In situations where there is only one shareholder present or participating, decisions may be deemed unanimous, eliminating the need for a traditional quorum.




QUESTION 5(d)

Q Makato Limited will be holding its Annual General Meeting (AGM) in thirty (30) days’ time. The meeting is set to be held at the Kasarani Gymnasium from 10.00 a.m.

Outline FOUR items to be indicated in the notice to be shared with the members of the company
A

Solution


Notice for Annual General Meeting (AGM)


The notice for Makato Limited's Annual General Meeting (AGM) should include the following items:

  • Date and Time: Clearly state the date and time of the AGM, specifying the start time (10:00 a.m. in this case).
  • Venue: Indicate the venue where the AGM will take place (Kasarani Gymnasium).
  • Agenda: Provide a detailed agenda listing the items to be discussed during the meeting, including any resolutions proposed for approval.
  • Financial Statements: Include a copy of the company's financial statements for the relevant period, as this is often a key agenda item for AGMs.
  • Proxy Form: If applicable, attach a proxy form allowing members to appoint a proxy to attend and vote on their behalf if they cannot attend in person.
  • Special Resolutions: If there are any special resolutions to be passed, clearly state them in the notice, and provide relevant details and explanations.
  • Quorum Requirements: Mention the quorum requirements for the AGM, specifying the minimum number of members needed for the meeting to proceed.
  • Questions and Comments: Encourage members to submit any questions or comments in advance and provide contact information for inquiries.
  • Attendance Confirmation: Include instructions for members to confirm their attendance or express any intention to participate in the AGM.
  • Any Other Relevant Information: Include any other relevant information, such as the procedures for voting, details on any proposed changes to the company's constitution, etc.




QUESTION 6(a)

Q You have been invited to speak at the board induction meeting of Ciffina Limited where three new directors have been appointed.

In relation to the above statement, outline FIVE statutory duties of a director.
A

Solution


Statutory Duties of a Director


As part of your speaking engagement at the board induction meeting of Ciffina Limited, it's important to highlight the statutory duties of a director. These duties, outlined by company law, include:

  • Duty to Act within Powers: Directors must act in accordance with the company's constitution and exercise their powers for the purposes for which they are conferred.
  • Duty to Promote the Success of the Company: Directors should act in a way that promotes the success of the company for the benefit of its shareholders and stakeholders, considering long-term consequences and interests.
  • Duty to Exercise Independent Judgment: Directors must exercise independent judgment and avoid conflicts of interest, ensuring that their decisions are not unduly influenced by external factors.
  • Duty to Exercise Reasonable Care, Skill, and Diligence: Directors are expected to exercise the care, skill, and diligence that would be reasonably expected of a person carrying out the same role, considering their knowledge and experience.
  • Duty to Avoid Conflicts of Interest: Directors must avoid situations where their personal interests conflict with the interests of the company. Any conflicts should be disclosed and managed appropriately.
  • Duty Not to Accept Benefits from Third Parties: Directors should not accept benefits from third parties that may influence their decision-making in a way that is not in the best interests of the company.
  • Duty to Declare Interest in Proposed Transaction or Arrangement: Directors must declare any direct or indirect interest in a proposed transaction or arrangement with the company and refrain from participating in the decision-making process.
  • Duty to Promote a Positive Company Culture: Directors should promote a positive company culture that aligns with the company's values and encourages ethical behavior throughout the organization.
  • Duty to Keep Proper Accounting Records: Directors are responsible for ensuring that the company maintains accurate and up-to-date accounting records and financial statements.
  • Duty to Comply with Legal Obligations: Directors must ensure that the company complies with all relevant laws, regulations, and statutory requirements.




QUESTION 6(b)

Q Discuss THREE remedies available to a lender who has acted in good faith and without knowledge that the company has borrowed money beyond its powers.
A

Solution


Potential Remedies for a Lender


  1. Enforcement of the Contract:

    If there is a valid and enforceable contract between the lender and the company, the lender may be entitled to enforce the terms of the contract. This could involve seeking repayment of the borrowed funds, including any interest or fees specified in the agreement. The lender may also have the right to enforce any security interests or guarantees provided by the company as collateral for the loan.

  2. Equitable Remedies:

    Equitable remedies are remedies that a court may grant based on fairness and justice. One common equitable remedy is specific performance, which compels a party to fulfill its contractual obligations. In the context of lending, a lender might seek an injunction to prevent the company from taking actions that could harm the lender's interests, such as disposing of assets that serve as collateral for the loan.

  3. Negotiation and Restructuring:

    Instead of taking a confrontational approach, the lender and the company may choose to negotiate a mutually agreeable solution. This could involve restructuring the loan terms, modifying the repayment schedule, or adjusting interest rates. Negotiation allows both parties to find a resolution that takes into consideration the financial health of the company and the lender's need for repayment. It may involve modifying the terms of the existing agreement to make it more feasible for the company to meet its obligations.

  4. Declaratory Relief:

    In some cases, a lender may seek declaratory relief from a court. This involves asking the court to issue a declaration clarifying the rights and obligations of the parties under the lending agreement. Declaratory relief can provide legal certainty and may be used to confirm the validity of the loan or to establish that the borrower has exceeded its borrowing powers.

  5. Waiver or Ratification:

    If the company, upon discovering its breach of borrowing powers, ratifies or affirms the unauthorized borrowing, it may impact the lender's remedies. In some jurisdictions, if the company acknowledges and accepts the unauthorized debt, the lender might be able to enforce the borrowing agreement based on this subsequent approval. However, the legal implications of waiver or ratification can vary, and it's essential to consider the specific circumstances and applicable laws.

  6. Default Provisions and Acceleration Clauses:

    Lending agreements often include default provisions and acceleration clauses that specify the consequences of a breach. If the company has breached its borrowing powers, the lender may have the right to declare the entire loan amount due immediately (acceleration). This can put additional pressure on the borrower to rectify the situation promptly or face more severe consequences, such as legal action or foreclosure on collateral.





QUESTION 6(c)

Q The role of a financial auditor is played by a person with the relevant competencies and independence to make appropriate judgement.

Identify FOUR persons who are disqualified from appointment as financial auditors.
A

Solution


Disqualification of Persons as Financial Auditors


The role of a financial auditor is played by a person with the relevant competencies and independence to make appropriate judgments. However, certain individuals are disqualified from appointment as financial auditors due to various reasons:

  1. Conflict of Interest:

    Individuals with a significant financial interest in the company being audited may be disqualified to maintain independence and objectivity. For example, a person owning a substantial amount of shares in the audited company might be considered conflicted.

  2. Former Employees or Officers:

    Former employees or officers of the company within a certain time frame might be disqualified to avoid potential bias or conflicts of interest. Their close association with the company could compromise their ability to provide an independent and objective audit.

  3. Close Relatives of Company Officers:

    Individuals who have close family relationships with officers or key employees of the audited company may be disqualified. This is to prevent any potential influence or bias that could compromise the auditor's independence.

  4. Financial Interest in the Outcome of the Audit:

    Persons who have a financial interest in the outcome of the audit, beyond the standard audit fee, may be disqualified. This includes situations where the auditor stands to gain or lose financially based on the results of the audit.

  5. Previous Violations or Sanctions:

    Individuals who have been subject to disciplinary actions, violations of auditing standards, or professional misconduct in the past may be disqualified from serving as auditors. Regulatory bodies and professional organizations maintain standards of conduct that auditors must adhere to.

  6. Lack of Professional Competence or Certification:

    Individuals who do not possess the necessary professional qualifications, certifications, or competence may be disqualified from acting as financial auditors. Most jurisdictions require auditors to meet specific educational and professional standards to ensure the quality and reliability of audit services.

  7. Legal Restrictions and Criminal Convictions:

    Individuals with certain criminal convictions or legal restrictions may be disqualified from serving as auditors. Serious criminal offenses or legal prohibitions related to dishonesty or financial misconduct may lead to disqualification.

  8. Auditor Independence Violations:

    Violations of independence rules and guidelines set by regulatory bodies or professional organizations can result in disqualification. Auditor independence is crucial for maintaining the integrity and reliability of the audit process.





QUESTION 6(d)

Q Highlight FIVE types of returns that must be delivered to the Registrar of Companies by a foreign company.
A

Solution


Returns to be Delivered by a Foreign Company


The following types of returns must be delivered to the Registrar of Companies by a foreign company:

  • Annual Returns:

    Foreign companies are typically required to submit annual returns, providing an overview of their activities, financial position, and other relevant details for the reporting period.

  • Financial Statements:

    Submission of audited financial statements is a common requirement. These statements offer a comprehensive view of the foreign company's financial performance and position during a specific period.

  • Changes in Corporate Structure:

    Any changes in the corporate structure, such as alterations to the company's directors, registered office address, or share capital, often need to be reported to the Registrar of Companies.

  • Particulars of Charges:

    Details of any charges created or modified by the foreign company over its assets must be filed. This helps maintain transparency regarding the company's financial obligations and liabilities.

  • Annual Compliance Certificates:

    Some jurisdictions may require foreign companies to submit annual compliance certificates, confirming adherence to local laws and regulations.

  • Tax Returns:

    Foreign companies are generally obligated to file tax returns, reporting their income, expenses, and other relevant financial information to the tax authorities of the host country.

  • Other Statutory Returns:

    Additional statutory returns or reports, as mandated by the laws of the host country, may need to be delivered to the Registrar of Companies by foreign entities.





QUESTION 7(a)

Q Directors are required to prepare a directors’ report to accompany the annual financial statements presented to members at an Annual General Meeting (AGM).

Describe FIVE matters that must be captured in a directors’ report.
A

Solution


Matters in Directors' Report


Directors are required to prepare a directors’ report to accompany the annual financial statements presented to members at an Annual General Meeting (AGM). The directors' report should capture the following key matters:

  • Financial Performance:

    Provide a comprehensive overview of the company's financial performance during the reporting period. This includes information on revenue, profit or loss, and other financial metrics.

  • State of Affairs:

    Describe the state of the company's affairs, covering aspects such as developments in the business, key achievements, challenges, and significant events affecting the company.

  • Principal Activities:

    Outline the principal activities of the company, including any changes in the nature of the business or the introduction of new products or services.

  • Dividends:

    Disclose any dividends declared or recommended by the board of directors. This includes the amount per share and the total dividend payout.

  • Future Prospects:

    Provide insights into the future prospects of the company, including any plans, projects, or strategies that may impact its performance in the coming periods.

  • Risks and Uncertainties:

    Discuss the major risks and uncertainties facing the company and the steps taken to mitigate these risks. This provides transparency to shareholders about potential challenges.

  • Corporate Governance:

    Include information on the company's corporate governance practices, compliance with governance codes, and any changes in governance structures or policies.

  • Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Matters:

    Address the company's approach to environmental, social, and governance issues. This is increasingly important for companies focusing on sustainability and responsible business practices.

  • Directors' Interests:

    Disclose any material interests, transactions, or arrangements involving directors and their related parties that could potentially impact the company.

  • Employees:

    Provide information on the company's relationship with its employees, including workforce composition, training, and any significant changes in employment policies.





QUESTION 7(b)

Q Identify FIVE instances when a court may appoint one or more competent inspectors to investigate the affairs of a company.
A

Solution


Instances when a Court may Appoint Inspectors for Company Affairs


In certain circumstances, a court may appoint one or more competent inspectors to investigate the affairs of a company. The following are instances that may trigger such appointments:

  • Suspected Fraud or Mismanagement:

    If there are reasonable grounds to suspect fraud or mismanagement within a company, a court may appoint inspectors to investigate the company's affairs thoroughly. This is to protect the interests of shareholders and stakeholders.

  • Disputes among Shareholders:

    When disputes among shareholders threaten the proper functioning of a company, and there are concerns about the management's conduct, a court may appoint inspectors to assess the situation and propose remedies.

  • Oppression of Minority Shareholders:

    If there are allegations of oppression or unfair treatment of minority shareholders, a court may appoint inspectors to examine the company's affairs and determine if any actions have been taken that are prejudicial to the interests of minority shareholders.

  • Request by Shareholders:

    Shareholders holding a significant percentage of the company's shares may petition the court for the appointment of inspectors if they believe there are irregularities or misconduct in the company's management.

  • Failure to Hold Annual General Meeting (AGM):

    If a company fails to hold its AGM within the prescribed time frame or there are concerns about the regularity of such meetings, a court may appoint inspectors to investigate and ensure compliance with statutory requirements.

  • Concerns Raised by Regulatory Authorities:

    Regulatory authorities, upon identifying issues of non-compliance or malpractices, may bring these concerns to the attention of a court. The court may then appoint inspectors to investigate and report on the company's affairs.

  • Public Interest:

    Instances where there is a clear public interest involved, such as concerns about the financial stability of a company or its impact on the broader economy, may prompt a court to appoint inspectors to safeguard public interests.

  • Breach of Company Law:

    If there are allegations or evidence of serious breaches of company law, a court may appoint inspectors to examine the company's compliance with legal provisions and recommend necessary actions.





QUESTION 7(c)

Q Highlight FIVE documents that a liquidator must lodge with the Registrar of Companies when making an application for voluntary winding up of a company.
A

Solution


Documents that a Liquidator must Lodge for Voluntary Winding Up Application


When making an application for the voluntary winding up of a company, a liquidator is required to lodge the following documents with the Registrar of Companies:

  • Declaration of Solvency:

    A declaration signed by the directors of the company, stating that they have made a full inquiry into the company's affairs and are of the opinion that the company can pay its debts in full within a specified period, not exceeding 12 months from the commencement of the winding up.

  • Notice of the Resolution:

    A notice of the resolution for voluntary winding up signed by the directors, indicating the date on which the resolution was passed and published in the official gazette or in a newspaper circulating in the company's registered office locality.

  • Copy of the Declaration:

    A copy of the declaration of solvency must be lodged with the Registrar of Companies, along with the notice of the resolution for voluntary winding up.

  • Consent of the Liquidator:

    The written consent of the proposed liquidator to act in the winding up of the company. The consent must be lodged with the Registrar.

  • Creditor's Special Resolution:

    If the company is unable to pay its debts, a special resolution passed by the company's creditors must be lodged with the Registrar within 10 days of the resolution being passed.

  • Notice of Appointment:

    Once the liquidator is appointed, a notice of the appointment must be lodged with the Registrar within 14 days of the appointment.

  • Final Meeting Report:

    After the final meeting of the company, a report on the meeting must be lodged with the Registrar within one week, indicating the manner in which the winding up has been conducted and the property of the company has been disposed of.





Comments on CPA past papers with answers:

New Unlock your potential with focused revision and soar towards success
Pass Kasneb Certification Exams Easily

Comments on:

CPA past papers with answers